Help me pick a summer shoe

It’s mid-April. Time to buy my summer wear everyday shoe.

What I’m looking for:  A wedge. Leather, the color of a Louis Vuitton bag’s trim turned brown from use (In case you’re wondering, the ones on the bottom right will turn). Two straps criss-crossed across the front and a strap that buckles across the ankle. A platform. A shoe I can wear with a dress or a pair of jeans, narrow or wide-legged.

Here’s 4 I’m considering. Which one will it be?

A B
C D

What do you think?  I’m putting it to a vote.  (BTW, if you have another one you think I should consider, please let me know.)